There are endless ways to write a story. Some authors pen their prose early in the morning or only at night. Others are daily writers or weekend wordsmiths.
Planners & Pantsers
But one of the largest dichotomies in our world comes down to one simple question: Are you a “plotter” or a “pantser?” Do you hold off on starting a new project until you have a scene-by-scene outline or do you discover your story as you write it?
There’s no right way, except the one that works for you.
Except that neither approach works for me.
“Pants-ing” leaves me with plotting dead ends, scenes that I painfully exorcise when I realize my story’s gone in another direction. “Plotting” leaves me wondering where’s the fun in writing a mystery if I’ve already sussed out the entire puzzle.
Backing Into A Third Approach
So I’ve backed my way into a third approach. I write the back cover blurb of my as-year-unwritten book to sketch out its major plot points. In fact, I won’t type “Chapter One” until I’m satisfied with that blurb.
What’s the benefit? If you read back cover blurbs—and I bet you do—you know that most highlight three or four of the major plot points traditional mysteries contain. They reflect the traditional three-act structure we know so well. When I finish drafting my blurb, I know generally where my story is going — and can avoid those dreaded dead-end scenes that need to be deleted. (All those beautiful words!) And I like the spontaneity of “pants-ing” my way through scenes that get me from one big picture plot point—one tentpole—to the next. I still get to discover the details of my story as I write them.
Connie Berry described the process as “tentpole plotting” in her recent MissDemeanors blog post. The major plot points are the poles that “hold up” the story, with still-to-be-written scenes leading from one tentpole to the next. I could write a tentpole outline, instead, I suppose. But writing a back cover blurb makes the outline process feel more like a game.
Let me show you how I use the format of a back cover blurb to brainstorm major plot points, using a bit of the blurb I wrote for my mystery,The Paris Mistress, as an illustration. Play along using your own Work In Progress.
Setting Up A Back Cover Blurb
1. Write an “everyday life is about to change” sentence(s). Your story probably begins here, and it’s where the reader gets a first glimpse of your sleuth.
Becca is eager to reach Paris to marry Daniel, who’s gone ahead to take up a new post there….
2. Write your “everyday life is turned upside down when…” sentence(s). Add your “sleuth has no choice but to investigate when…” sentence.
But their idyllic prenuptial life unravels when they accept an invitation to reside with Benjamin Franklin, America’s ambassador to France…When a man is murdered on the roof of Dr. Franklin’s home, he calls on Becca and Daniel to investigate.
3.Write one or two “things go from bad to worse” sentences.
The duo’s investigation points to members of Dr. Franklin’s inner circle.
4. Write a sentence or two to suggest the climax.
As Becca and Daniel race from Paris to the gilded halls of Versailles, they discover their lives are at risk and that the stakes for America are higher than they could have imagined.
And there you have it: another way to brainstorm the start of your mystery plot. I hope you’ll give this a try. You may surprise yourself with a back cover blurb that serves you well through the process of crafting your own wildly creative story.

Hi Mally, So you’re a plotster? I like to think of this as the “I know I’m driving to California” method. I, however, am a straight up plotter – or became one when I started writing thrillers. I’ve heard other writers say what you did about plotting. Like it’s unmotivating. I have to say I’m a happy plotter.
Loved this post.
Thanks, Lane, I love hearing about the variations in how we all write and develop our stories, though I think of myself more as a pants-ter than a plotster. 😉
Mally, that is an excellent exercise! I bet it would work for a short story too. Lately, I’ve actually started doing something like this. I write an extensive synopsis, for my eyes only, and only start writing the novel when I feel the synopsis makes sense. Then, the novel goes off the rails anyway, but at least I know where it starts, where it goes, and some of the stuff in between. I found detailed outlines before I write don’t work very well because they are imposing actions from the outside in, rather than the characters acting from the inside out. I’m going to use your example for my next story!
I tried writing a detailed outline once. It gave me such a sense of security…until my plot pulled me in another direction around page 50. And I think you’re right. The problem was that I was imposing actions “from the outside in” on new-to-me characters, who developed over time as I wrote. That process of character development forced changes to my outline. Let me know how the exercise works for you!
This is so interesting and helpful, Mally! I know some authors who struggle to write this kind of blurb even after their book is finished. I’m going to try it next time.
I’m one of those people! Though I’ve got a finished book and complete synopsis, I struggle with back cover copy.
Thanks, Connie! The questions sound simple, but they’re not, of course. If you do try out the exercise, let me know how it goes!
Mally, I love this fill-in-the-blanks approach to plot-sing. It leaves room for the unexpected but keeps a big-picture focus on the essential elements.
Exactly! Part of the difficulty in writing a back-cover blurb after the fact is that we’ve just finished drafting 300 pages or so of plot twists, reversals, subplots, and on and on. It takes so much effort to step back and regain the big-picture focus needed to craft a blurb.
Exactly! I am a pantser but I tend to write the blurb first to keep me honest and on track!
What a great, succinct way to define the benefits of our early blurbs!
Mally, this is very helpful. I’m a panster and though my process is a little different, I’ve also found writing the jacket copy keeps me on track. However, I don’t usually do it until I’m partially into the book and have an what it’s about.
One of the things I love about writing is that there’s no one “right” way to do…just about anything!
Thanks, Mally, this is interesting and helpful!
Glad you thought it was useful!
Mally,
Wonderful advice. I tend to do the same thing. It helps to crystallize the story in my head.
Thanks for the kind words, Daniella!
Mally, I really love this technique! It makes good sense when you think about it right? I will definitely be using it on my next book…
Marni, I hope it sparks ideas for many more of your wonderful stories!
Now that I’m (finally!!) querying the book I’ve been writing forever . . . this sounds like an interesting idea to get going on the new project I’m just starting to figure out.
Miss our lunches — hope we can figure out something, somewhere!
So glad to hear that you’re querying the book, Catherine! And, yes, let’s definitely get together.
I LOVE your 4 questions! Perfect for getting my mostly-pantser-partly-plotter brain in order! I usually start with an oh-yes-I know-the-opener to the ‘this is the murder’ to ‘oh, this is what happens with the relationships’ to ‘the end’. Un-un. Currently working to shave 5,000 words off a MS I’ve edited 3 x’s! The characters totally got away from me and I’ve GOT to save some for the next 2 volumes. But that’s why I hesitate to make a die-hard plot outline–the characters have lives and carry me with them. But your 4 questions will help keep things on a better track. Thank you SO much!
Good luck cutting those 5000 words, Sharon! (I feel your pain.) and let us know if those questions help you stay on track. ????
Oh, I will! My query letter is DONE, so I just have to get those words gone, and I’m onto the next step! My writing coach Ellie Alexander calls it “killing your darlings”…lol!
Good luck cutting those 5000 words, Sharon! (I feel your pain.) and let us know if those questions help you stay on track. ????
Love the idea! I tend to write the blurb from lines I’ve jotted down in emails to my friends about the novel!
I’m a plotter and tend to overengineer my novels but yes occasionally my characters take off in unexpected directions. This is exciting but also stressful because then my big outline gets reworked. I do write the “pole tent” method (didn’t know it had a name!) with the poles being exciting scenes that haunt me.
Mally, thanks for sharing. I plan to try this method for my next novel 🙂
So glad you found the post interesting. Since I’m a big fan of your series, I especially love hearing about your writing process!
Great advice, especially for us compulsive pantsers!